Powerful Ways to Get Ahead of Challenging Student Behavior Blog Series: Part 5
Think about the students who take up most of your time and attention during the school day.
We'd guess you can name them pretty quickly.
They're the students you're checking on, making plans for, problem-solving with colleagues about, and sometimes losing sleep over.
And understandably so. They need our support.
They are getting a lot of attention from you, and they know it.
How could they not?
But they're not the only ones who notice.
Now think about the students who are doing exactly what we've asked them to do.
The ones who come to class, follow expectations, participate, and get through the day without needing much from us.
The students who can sometimes go unnoticed because they're not causing problems.
They do everything we're asking, and what do they get in return?
Do they feel like they're getting that same attention?
Sometimes, not so much.
And here's where things get interesting.
Our students are watching who gets our attention.
They're paying attention to what it takes to get it.
And what they notice can influence what they do next.
Kids Are Paying Attention to Our Attention
Kids are smart.
When students see their peers getting more interaction, more conversation, and more connection because they're not following expectations, they notice.
Some may consciously decide to try those behaviors themselves. Others may begin making different choices without even realizing why.
Because kids want connection with us.
And sometimes, they don't care how they get it.
We aren't suggesting that we stop supporting students with challenging behaviors. Quite the opposite.
But we need to pay attention to what our attention is reinforcing.
Don't Let Green Turn Lime
Think about student behavior in three levels:
Green: On target and consistently meeting expectations.
Yellow: At risk and may need additional support.
Red: Below target and requiring more intensive intervention.
These colors help us think about how students are doing with behavioral expectations, recognizing that their needs and behaviors can change over time.
Naturally, behavior in the red gets considerable attention. The needs can be significant, and sometimes there are safety concerns.
We pay attention to behavior in the yellow, too, particularly when we see signs that a student is beginning to struggle.
But when behavior is consistently in the green?
We often assume it will stay that way.
And here's the thing.
Green doesn't necessarily stay green.
When students consistently meet expectations but receive little acknowledgment, while watching others receive significant attention for challenging behaviors, they may begin making different choices.
That's how green can start turning lime.
But the reverse is also true.
When we intentionally notice and praise on-target behavior, other students notice, too.
They see which behaviors earn our attention, encouragement, and connection.
And just as challenging behavior can influence students' choices, positive behavior can, too.
We can help keep green from turning lime while encouraging behavior that's in the yellow to move toward green.
That's what it means to grow the green.
How Do We Grow the Green?
We get so excited when a student who's been struggling finally meets an expectation that we sometimes forget to acknowledge the student who's been meeting it all along.
And that's where we need to be intentional.
Catch Them Doing It Right
Look for the behaviors that are so consistent they've become almost invisible.
The student who gets started without being reminded.
The student who consistently treats others with kindness.
The student who's ready to learn, day after day.
Notice them. And let them know you've noticed.
Don't assume they know you appreciate what they're doing simply because you haven't had to redirect them.
Make It Personal
Not every student wants a public shout-out.
Some love that kind of recognition. Others would rather have a quiet conversation, a handwritten note, or a little one-on-one attention.
Know your students well enough to understand what makes them feel seen and appreciated.
Connect Without Waiting for a Problem
Think about how many conversations we have with students because something has gone wrong.
How often do we initiate those same conversations with students who are doing well?
Ask about their game. Follow up on something they told you last week. Stop by their desk just to check in.
Not because they need redirection.
Because you care about them.
Notice Consistency, Not Just Improvement
When a student who's been struggling has a great day, we celebrate.
And we should!
But what about the student who's been having great days all along?
Their consistency deserves acknowledgment, too.
Fair Isn't Always Equal
Sometimes, we need to remind students, colleagues, and even ourselves that fair doesn't always mean equal.
We wouldn't expect every student to need the same academic supports, so why would we expect every student to need the same behavioral supports?
Some students need more frequent check-ins, individualized plans, or additional opportunities to connect with adults. Others need less intensive support, but they still need to be noticed and valued.
That can be difficult for students and even other educators to understand, especially when one student appears to receive more attention or a different consequence for the same behavior.
We need to explain that our expectations remain high for everyone, but our supports and responses may differ based on individual needs.
And while we can't share another student's private information, we can explain the thinking behind our approach.
Fair isn't everyone getting the same thing. It's everyone getting what they need to be successful.
And every student needs connection.
Grow the Green
Throughout this series, we've spent a lot of time talking about students with challenging behaviors.
And for good reason.
These students need us to understand what's driving their behavior, examine how we're responding, and develop thoughtful plans to help them succeed.
They deserve our time, attention, and support.
But so do the students who are already meeting expectations.
The goal isn't to spend less time supporting students who are struggling. It's to be more intentional about connecting with everyone.
Our attention is powerful. Where we direct it matters.
When we intentionally recognize the behaviors we want to see more of, we can help prevent on-target behavior from slipping while encouraging more students to meet expectations.
We don't want students to have to struggle to get our attention.

